Goodfellas Pizza

4.5 ( 144 reviews )
Checking... 10:00 AM - 9:00 PM See Hours
$10–20
251 W Lee Hwy Suite 231, Warrenton, VA 20186, United States
+1 540-935-2266

Goodfellas Pizza in Warrenton, VA, has carved a niche for itself as a beloved local pizza joint. Many patrons share their experiences, noting the rapid service and the freshness of their offerings. Michael Switzer, a recent customer, highlighted the standout Indian paneer pizza and the delightful margarita pizza, stating that Goodfellas has quickly become his favorite pizza spot. His journey with the restaurant began with an average experience, but subsequent orders transformed his perception, emphasizing the restaurant's consistent improvement.

Tess Hill also appreciated the efficiency of the delivery service, enjoying both a small pizza and a limoncello cake, although she wished for a crispier crust. Meanwhile, Jeff Davis praised the supreme calzone, especially their exceptional customer service when they rectified an order mix-up, reinforcing their commitment to satisfaction.

In a community where good food matters, pam jenkins and erika h echo sentiments of quality and flavor, with pam specifically enamored by the Goodfellas supreme. With a welcoming atmosphere and passionate staff, Goodfellas Pizza proves that good food and excellent service create a memorable dining experience worth revisiting.

Amenities and More

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
  • Service options
    • Offers kerbside pickup
    • Has no-contact delivery
    • Offers delivery
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Popular for
    • Popular for lunch
    • Popular for dinner
    • Good for solo dining
  • Offerings
    • Serves comfort food
    • Quick bite
  • Dining options
    • Serves lunch
    • Serves dinner
    • Has catering
    • Serves dessert
  • Atmosphere
    • Casual
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards
  • Children
    • Good for kids
    • Has kids' menu
  • Parking
    • Free of charge street parking
    • Free parking lot
    • Plenty of parking

Reviews For Goodfellas Pizza

Michael Switzer
Jun 26,2025
Update: Ok. So my family and I have ordered twice since our first order which was average. The past 2 times have been awesome! The pizza has been amazing and we really love the Indian paneer pizzas. The margarita pizza is also delicious. They have been quick, polite, and the food is fresh. Good fellas is becoming my favorite local pizza spot! Definitely recommend you give them a try. ****************************************** Original review/order............... Ordered 2 pizzas, a cheese steak, and humus. - Pan pizza was ok, crust wasn't the best. Sauce was good, topping were fresh. - Regular cheese pizza was good, regular crust is preferred. - Cheese steak was ok. Pretty basic and comparable to most pizza/sub joints. - Humus was good. Overall a 2.5 star experience. We will give Good Fellas another try, but it is not our favorite pizza place.
Tess Hill
Jun 23,2025
I ordered a small pizza and a piece of limoncello cake for delivery, it arrived faster than expected. Both the pizza and cake were good, I could have the crust a little crispier.
Jeff Davis
May 20,2025
I love the supreme calzone, and perhaps a little too much. I came specifically today to applaud them for making an oversight more than right. I placed an order Saturday night, and when I arrived to pick it up, the whole place was dark. Not a soul in there; not sure what happened. I showed up Tuesday with my order confirmation, and they not only refunded my money, they gave me a free medium pepperoni pie and fountain drink. I can’t rate the atmosphere as I only get carryout or delivery. Everyone there is very kind and it does seem quite clean.
pam jenkins
May 17,2025
Best pizza around made and served by some awesome folks. One day I'll try some of they're other menu items but at the present time I'm hooked on the goodfellas supreme. Thank you for being awesome!
erika h
May 3,2025
Quick and amazing service! The pizza tasted fresh and full of flavor;))
Chris Berry
Apr 14,2025
Amazing burgers! I always argue they are better than 5 guys. I’m the manager of Verizon right behind there and eat there atleast 2x monthly
John Kuvakas
Apr 12,2025
I was skeptical when this place won the "Best Pizza in Warrenton" award. But, I've become a believer. The facility is small with but a few seats and tables. It is more designed for carry out. The service is impeccable and the food comes quickly. There's a full menu including appetizers and deserts. Try the cannolis! I have to admit, their Chicago Style Meat Lovers Pizza is the best Chicago pizza I've had this side of the Appalachians. I've been looking for authentic Chicago style pizza for years, hoping to find it wihtout having to drive for 12 hours. Goodfella's has it! Prices are fair to moderate. They have vegetarian options.
zippity dooda
Mar 25,2025
I conveniently timed my feedstore run with lunch. The crust and the marinara are the make or break for a pizza, calzone, Stromboli. Good Fellas Warrenton’s choice of ingredients and finesse— created a perfect combination of flavor and texture. Portions are enough to share, though I was grateful I didn’t have to share my dessert! Chocolate Mousse Cake— mmm made me chew slower out of pleasure! I am not a chef or a baker so I may get terms wrong (I’m just a foodie)— it seemed to have like a thin layer of chocolate... like a ganache maybe, a dense cake that wasn’t heavy (how is that even possible?!) with a very light and fluffy chocolate mousse between the layers. OMG. I will be back. The menu is extensive— I recommend checking it out before hand. I saw several other meals and desserts I look forward to trying, next visit.

Add a Review

Quality
Location
Price
Space
Service

Location

Appreciated by Others

Sunrise Coney Island
(945 review)
Sunrise Coney Island
  • 22935 Van Dyke Ave, Warren, MI 48089, United States
American restaurant
+1 586-759-0770
Dinings SW3
(693 review)
Dinings SW3
  • Walton House, Lennox Gardens Mews, Walton St, London SW3 2JH, United Kingdom
Japanese restaurant
+44 20 3597 9706
Texas Burger
(594 review)
Texas Burger
  • 8 Lindsay St, Fenelon Falls, ON K0M 1N0, Canada
Hamburger restaurant
+1 705-887-4282
Showmars Arrowood
(929 review)
Showmars Arrowood
  • 2316 W Arrowood Rd, Charlotte, NC 28217, United States
greek restaurant
+1 704-522-0075
ONe eighteen
(275 review)
ONe eighteen
  • 111 W Main St, Midland, MI 48640, United States
American restaurant
+1 989-633-6099
Castle Perk Espresso
(278 review)
Castle Perk Espresso
  • 1008 Zehnder St, Sumner, WA 98390, United States
cafe
+1 253-891-7273
Bun That.
(118 review)
Bun That.
  • 68 Weston Rd, Meir, Stoke-on-Trent ST3 6AD, United Kingdom
hamburger restaurant
+44 1782 442522
Restaurant Los Agaves
(197 review)
Restaurant Los Agaves
  • C. Carrera sn, 23520 Miraflores, B.C.S., Mexico
restaurant
+52 624 161 2234
Café Pierre Jean Jase
(430 review)
Café Pierre Jean Jase
  • 550 Rue de Montréal, Sherbrooke, QC J1H 3V8, Canada
Restaurant
+1 819-829-5927
Bonchon Arden
(411 review)
Bonchon Arden
  • 1600 Ethan Way Unit 40, Sacramento, CA 95825, United States
Asian fusion restaurant
+1 916-333-2383